Lumpectomy vs. Mastectomy: What Women Should Know
Key Pointers:
- Lumpectomy removes the tumour with margin; mastectomy removes the whole breast.
- Lumpectomy usually pairs with radiotherapy; mastectomy may reduce recurrence risk.
- Choice depends on tumour size/location, genetics, health, and personal preference.
- Reconstruction options exist for mastectomy; oncoplastic techniques aid cosmesis.
- Consult a lumpectomy surgeon to align cancer control with body goals.
One of the most important and personal decisions you’ll make is choosing between a lumpectomy and a mastectomy. Both are effective surgical treatments, but they differ in scope, recovery, and emotional impact.
If you’re currently navigating your treatment options or supporting a loved one through it, understanding the key differences can help make the journey feel a little more manageable. Here’s what every woman should know before deciding.
What Is a Lumpectomy?
A lumpectomy, also known as breast-conserving surgery, involves removing only the tumour and a small margin of surrounding tissue. The goal is to eliminate the cancer while preserving as much of the breast as possible.
It’s often followed by radiation therapy to reduce the risk of recurrence, especially in early-stage cancers.
Ideal for:
- Small, localised tumours
- Early-stage breast cancer
- Women who prefer to keep their natural breast shape
What Is a Mastectomy?
A mastectomy involves removing the entire breast, and in some cases, surrounding lymph nodes or muscle tissue, depending on the spread of the cancer. For some women, reconstruction can be done at the same time or later.
There are different types of mastectomies, such as simple, skin-sparing, and nipple-sparing, each tailored to specific clinical needs and personal preferences.
Ideal for:
- Larger or multiple tumours
- High risk of recurrence
- Genetic mutations (e.g., BRCA1 or BRCA2)
- Women who prefer not to have radiation therapy
Lumpectomy vs. Mastectomy
Feature | Lumpectomy | Mastectomy |
Breast preservation | Yes | No |
Radiation therapy | Typically required | Often not needed |
Recovery time | Shorter | Longer, especially with reconstruction |
Recurrence risk | Slightly higher (but manageable with radiation) | Lower |
Cosmetic impact | Less visible change | Complete breast removal |
How to Decide
Choosing between a lumpectomy and mastectomy isn’t only about medical suitability; it’s also about how you feel about your body, lifestyle, and long-term peace of mind. Some women value breast preservation; others prioritise a more aggressive approach to reduce future risk.
Factors that influence your decision may include:
- Tumour size and location
- Breast size relative to the tumour
- Overall health and age
- Family history and genetic factors
- Willingness or ability to undergo radiation
- Emotional comfort with outcomes
Speak With a Specialist You Trust
Whatever choice you make, it’s important to have a thorough conversation with a lumpectomy surgeon or breast specialist who understands your condition and your concerns. Both options can offer excellent long-term survival rates when part of a well-planned treatment strategy.
Dr. Radhika Lakshmanan and the team at The Radhika Breast & General Surgery Clinic are here to offer compassionate, individualised guidance to help you understand your surgical options and choose the path that aligns with your health goals and personal values. Book a consultation today to explore what’s right for you.